The Remake of Zelda: Nintendo's Half-Measure Problem

When Nintendo showed off its Switch 2 remake of The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time earlier in September, I had the same first thought as a lot of folks: Nintendo sure did hire that man.

In the weeks since, though, I’ve warmed on the remake’s new art style. Yes, the glassy-eyed characters give off an uncanny first impression, and the realistic lighting and detailed clothing can call to mind Unreal Engine 5 asset flips. But these aren't purposeless decisions—the cherubic character designs seem inspired by puppet theater and porcelain dolls, and the environments are aiming for a capital-r-Romantic style, not simply photorealism. Meanwhile, combat looks snappy and satisfying, and there appear to be more changes under the hood than just the addition of a jump button.

Yet there’s still something that feels off about the whole project, and it's not Link's appearance when sopping wet. Criticisms focusing on the graphics alone are missing the Kokiri Forest for the Great Deku Trees: more worrying is how this appears to be a new coat of paint on a nearly one-to-one remake of the Nintendo 64 original, down to enemy placements and dungeon designs.

In returning to Ocarina with overhauled graphics but faithful gameplay, I fear Nintendo is creating a game of half-measures that will fail to satisfy both nostalgia-seekers and those looking for a new take on a classic. And because this remake will be the only version of Ocarina available to purchase on modern consoles, Nintendo is looking more and more like another media company that can’t stop trying to remake its own past: The Walt Disney Company.

A Remake of Half Measures

The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time (2026) for Switch 2

First, let’s get this out of the way: remakes aren’t necessarily a bad thing.

As easy as it would be to dismiss all remakes as IP slop, there are loads of valid reasons why they get greenlit, as Jason Schreier outlines in this video. For developers and publishers, selling a safe product to a built-in audience is certainly a piece of it. But remakes are also useful for training teams on new tools and pipelines, not to mention keeping employees busy (and employed) when they otherwise wouldn't have anything to work on. Remakes can even pave the way for new game development, as we've seen before in the Zelda series—studio Grezzo’s 2019 remake of Link’s Awakening eventually led to them making 2024’s Echoes of Wisdom, the first new 2D Zelda game in over ten years.

On the consumer side, too, the benefits go beyond being able to access classics on new systems. Remakes update games to modern standards, sometimes by simply offering graphics that look good on 4K TVs, other times by removing frictional design elements and offering accessibility features. And then there's appeal—a graphically impressive, cruft-free remake can be more attractive to new audiences who might not have the patience or know-how for retro games. I have a friend who got to share his love of Star Fox 64 with his child a few months ago thanks to its flashy, faithful Switch 2 remake. It's hard to imagine the same kid sitting through the Nintendo 64 original, a game with worse graphical fidelity than the average YouTube Kids video.

Yet despite these things, it still feels strange to me that Ocarina's remake will feature boldly updated graphics for gameplay that looks largely the same underneath. 

The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time 3D (2011) for Nintendo 3DS 

Part of my concern is we’ve already been here. 2011’s 3DS remake Ocarina of Time 3D (also by Grezzo) faithfully recreated the look and feel of the Nintendo 64 Ocarina with more detailed character models and textures. That remake is now stuck on a handheld that ceased production in 2020—why not port an enhanced version to Switch? 

On top of that, the original game isn’t at all unapproachable. I had a great time replaying it via the Nintendo Switch Online + Expansion Pack subscription service a couple years ago. Its gameplay is dated in some ways, and its graphics might not attract 2026 kids in droves, but it’s a far cry from the jankiness found in other retro games like Tomb Raider or Glover.

With the original Ocarina and the 3DS remake out there, it's a bit disappointing to see Nintendo pumping so many resources into yet another faithful remake. Yes, trailers show a revised layout for Kakariko Village and a new bombable wall in the Water Temple, but everything else they’ve shown off looks at least 90% similar. We’re almost certainly going to hit the same story beats and go to the same rooms in the same temples that have been around since 1998.

If Nintendo were going to do this remake at all, it’s hard not to wish they’d gone farther. Capcom's Resident Evil remakes successfully preserve the spirit of the original games while modernizing the design and offering new experiences. What would walking through a completely redesigned Hyrule Castle Town feel like? How might the Shadow Temple feel if they shook up some of the Lens of Truth puzzles to disorient veteran players? What if they gave us a proper Light Temple? We likely won't ever know, because the creative mandate for this remake seems to be "faithful," not "fresh."

In the same vein, as controversial as the new art style has proven, they frankly could’ve gone a lot farther. The character models may look like puppets, but they move and articulate like humans at a glossy 60 frames per second. The semi-realistic environments are as polished as you'd expect from Nintendo, but they still look like they could belong to any old open-world game like Wuthering Waves. I find myself wishing they’d explored bold, playful styles like South of Midnight’s variable frame rate animation or the Link's Awakening remake's faux tilt-shift photography. Instead, we get a game that’s trying to split the difference between hyperrealism and stylization, a choice that all but ensures it will fall into the uncanny valley. 

This all raises an even bigger question: by updating the game’s art design to modern sensibilities while keeping its skeleton in place, does the remake risk losing something vital?

The Ocarina of (Its) Time

The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time (1998) for Nintendo 64 

The Nintendo 64 is a liminal console. When it released in September 1996, it stood at the forefront of a transitory moment for gaming, the beginning of a 3D revolution, with hardware that would soon be exceeded in leaps and bounds by the GameCube, PlayStation 2, and Xbox. It was a moment of technology advancing overnight while game designers scrambled to catch up.

Ocarina of Time began development concurrently with Super Mario 64 and Mario Kart 64, the latter two of which released in 1996. By the time Ocarina hit store shelves in 1998, Nintendo had already figured out some 3D design principles, but Ocarina still found new ways to pioneer. It introduced mechanics like Z-targeting to facilitate combat in 3D spaces. It set new standards for how to navigate environments and solve puzzles in action RPGs. And while its graphics weren’t as impressive as the pre-rendered cutscenes from Final Fantasy VII over on PlayStation, everything in Ocarina was rendered in-engine, giving a uniform look to the Nintendo 64's deepest and most expansive adventure.

As with many trend-setters, Ocarina’s greatness is inexorably rooted in the constraints of its hardware. The once expansive Hyrule Field is flat and barren by modern standards, but that makes its landmarks memorable. Dungeon geometry is simple and low-poly, meaning it’s generally obvious where players can go and what objects are interactable. Combat and enemy AI are basic—just what the doctor ordered for easing players into new mechanics like Z-targeting. 

None of this is incidental; these are smart game design decisions made for the hardware and era the game released in. Even the titular ocarina wouldn't be the same without the Nintendo 64’s controller; composer Koji Kondo carefully chose 5 notes to map to the controller’s radial C-buttons and A button, and through that limitation, created some of gaming’s best and most influential music.

The same goes for the original's visuals. Its 90s-anime character designs translate well to blocky textures and low-poly character models. Bold color palates and simple environment textures pop on CRT displays and make gameplay elements clear. Frightening bosses like Queen Ghoma and Bongo Bongo fight in dark arenas, stylistic choices that also ensure the Nintendo 64’s limited memory won't be overloaded. Even its clunkiest limitations, like how it runs at a locked 20 frames per second, give it a quasi-cinematic air that the faithful 3DS remake can't capture. 

It's in those constraints that Ocarina finds artfulness. The omnipresent music of the game's opening hours gives way to the diegetic sounds of the Kokiri Forest when Saria bids Link farewell. The ravages of Hyrule in the future are communicated through clear changes to locations Link visited in the past. There is a genuine weirdness on the game's periphery—oddballs like the rock-munching Gorons and gramophone-toting Guru Guru are made endearing through simple animations, while NPCs like the Happy Mask Salesman and Skull Kids are all the more unnerving for their lack of detail. And there’s a TikTok-ready uncanniness to the spaces they inhabit—fog obscuring distant locations, polygonal shapes that can only gesture at the environmental features they represent, the occasional pre-rendered background that clashes with Link’s character model. There is danger lurking behind the black tunnels in the Lost Woods, something horrible at the bottom of the well, a chilling feeling in your stomach when you first see one of the low-fidelity Redeads and can’t quite tell what’s going on with its face.

It is within and because of its limitations that Ocarina is brilliant. 

The Switch 2 remake overhauling the original’s graphics but not the gameplay risks unmooring Ocarina from its crucial historical context. Adding hit-stop and flashy effects to combat makes it snappy, but this will only do so much if we’re fighting the same enemies in the same small arenas. Bringing the low-poly character designs into the high-res 2020s is a fine goal, but what looks good as a flat face texture has a different effect when rendered in lifelike 3D. The quiet, aching longing as Saria bids you goodbye cannot be improved by voice acting. 

As it stands, unless Nintendo is hiding something up its sleeve, one of the better outcomes for this remake will be a game that looks new but feels antiquated. At worst, it will attempt to recapture the original’s magic and fall flat. Nintendo has created a no-win situation for itself.

And that’s made all the worse because of…

The Preservation Problem

Nintendo Switch Online + Expansion Pack

When it releases in November 2026, the Switch 2 remake of Ocarina of Time will be the only version available to purchase on modern consoles.

The key word here is purchase. Yes, you can emulate the Nintendo 64 original via the Nintendo Switch Online + Expansion Pack subscription, but this requires an active subscription and reliable internet connection. There is no option to buy the original game from Nintendo and keep it downloaded forever on a Switch or Switch 2. 

The EULAs that govern our late-capitalist hellscape mean we don’t truly own the game licenses we purchase (and essentially never have), but there is still a significant difference between access to a game via subscription versus a one-time purchase. Price is one—the Expansion Pack starts at $50 USD per year. But beyond price, there are the hurdles to the general public knowing this option even exists. To play the original Ocarina today, you have to learn about the subscription service, pay to join the correct tier, and then separately download the Nintendo 64 – Nintendo Classics app from the Nintendo eShop. None of these are insurmountable barriers, of course—but for the less tech-savvy folks out there, they are barriers.

Meanwhile, the upcoming remake of Ocarina will surely be plastered on the front page of the eShop and sold on store shelves at Wal-Mart and Target. This means that for some gamers, the remake will be the only version of the game they know exists. One wonders if Nintendo is okay with this.

By far, the biggest risk of locking the original game to a subscription is that Nintendo could, at any time and for any reason, decide to change their subscription offerings. What if they follow the lead of Xbox GamePass and jack up prices, or gate Ocarina behind an even more expensive tier? What if they decide to put all their chips on the new remake and delist the original game? That type of decision feels unthinkable—but then, five years ago, it would’ve felt unthinkable for HBO and Warner Bros. to delist all of the classic Looney Tunes shorts. HBO did that in 2024 for a tax write-off. We must not forget the Nintendo we're talking about is the same company that's locked Ocarina of Time 3D and two other enhanced Zelda ports, The Wind Waker HD and Twilight Princess HD, to their original consoles for over a decade.

Nintendo is a company seeking to profit off us, not a friend or benefactor. The Nintendo of 2026 choosing to make old games accessible could easily become the Nintendo of 2030 deciding the originals aren’t synergistic to their brand, or that server costs have become too high. It should not be incumbent on gamers to purchase original hardware on eBay, or to jump through legally gray emulation hoops, to experience major works in the way they were originally intended. Yet for all of the access Nintendo currently provides, we are left to their whims.

And that finally leads us to…

The Disney of It All  

Disney's The Lion King (2019)

My second thought upon seeing the Ocarina remake was about The Lion King.

Like the original Ocarina, the 1994 Lion King movie defined my childhood—it was the first film my parents took me to see in theaters. I wore down our VHS copy and played the Windows 95 activity center game for years.

In 2019, Walt Disney Pictures released its star-studded “live-action” remake of The Lion King. It garnered mixed critical reception for hewing so closely to the original’s story while ditching its stylized 2D animation in favor of photorealistic CGI. It also made a dizzying $1.6 billion at the box office, all but guaranteeing Disney would continue remaking nostalgic classics. In the last two years, they've brought us similarly misguided remakes of Lilo & Stitch and Moana. 

Right now, Nintendo has Disney live-action remake problem on its hands. Two of the company's highest-profile 2026 releases are high-def remakes of Nintendo 64 games. Regardless of its controversies, Switch 2's Ocarina will surely sell millions of copies. The question is what they'll do next.

Nintendo could choose to parlay the development team’s experience on the Ocarina remake towards production of brand-new Zelda games. In a best-case scenario, we might even get two lines of Zelda games—one that puts new spins on the classic dungeoneering formula, another that carries on Breath of the Wild and Tears of the Kingdom’s open-world experimentation. 

But that’s wishful thinking. Financially, Nintendo will be incentivized to push out more remakes. Will we see Majora’s Mask and Wind Waker remade in new art styles next? Or will they go back to the franchise well for remakes of Super Mario 64 and Kirby 64: The Crystal Shards? I can hardly conceive of those games translating well to a remake, but if Nintendo smells money, they'll probably try.

And yet, there's an even uglier Disney-owned specter hanging over this topic: the original Star Wars trilogy. In the 1997 Special Editions and 2004 DVD releases, George Lucas and Lucasfilm significantly updated the original movies to add CGI effects, change color grading, and make a slew of other edits. These changes were panned at the time and only aged like milk, creating a category-5 hurricane of fandom controversy that still rages on. But nowadays, thanks to Lucas and Disney, these are the only releases of Star Wars you can legally stream or purchase. The original versions of the trilogy are available now through decaying VHS copies and remarkable multi-year fan efforts like Project 4K77.

I still think there is value to be found in remakes, remasters, and revisions. But there is power and value in the originals, too. Fans know this, and so the originals will always live on in one way or another. With this massive Ocarina remake on the horizon, the question I return to most isn't whether it will be good—it is what precisely Nintendo will keep around, and what it will try to bury.


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Chainsaw Man and the Art of Adaptation

The Best Anime of 2025

The Top Fifteen Anime of 2022